ATO Vs Gardening Clubs

The ATO’s Crusade Against Gardening Clubs: Bureaucracy vs. Backyard Joy

Across Australia, a quiet war is being waged against some of our most wholesome community groups: gardening clubs. These humble gatherings of retirees, green thumbs, and hobby growers are now being targeted by the ATO with bureaucratic red tape and outrageous demands for proof of their not-for-profit status — despite many already being officially registered as such.

Why the sudden pressure? To chase loose change. We’re talking about clubs that make cups of tea and raffles, raising barely a few dollars to cover hall hire and bus trips and insurance costs.

Yet the ATO, in its insatiable greed, is demanding decades of records and threatening penalties if clubs can’t ‘prove’ their innocence. Some are even being back-charged for taxes never owed.

It’s absurd — and it’s cruel. Several clubs have already shut down, unable to cope with the demands or stress placed on their elderly committee members. And clubs have shut down as no one wants to take a position at the annual general meeting and that was that - gone!

Gardening Clubs: More Than Just Dirt & Dahlias

Gardening clubs are not just about growing plants — they are lifelines of mental health, community, and continuity. For many seniors, especially those who have undergone hip or knee replacements, or are living with debilitating illnesses, getting into the garden is no longer possible — but gathering with their lifelong friends for a cuppa, an egg sandwich, and a slice of fruit cake is the medicine they still rely on.

These moments of connection ward off loneliness, reduce depression, and give purpose. Chasing these clubs for trivial tax forms is not only administratively absurd — it is a violation of the quiet dignity and social healing these communities bring.

Let’s be honest — these are the people who built our country.

They shared cuttings, not profits. They deserve our gratitude and protection, not persecution.

Want to know more about the requirements? The ATO’s demands for gardening clubs include:

Proof of not-for-profit status (even if already registered)
Clear financial records going back years
Written constitutions and documentation of all committee decisions

For elderly volunteers with no formal bookkeeping skills, this is overwhelming.

📎 ATO guidelines on not-for-profits

📎 ABC coverage of club closures and pushback

The Tax Trap

Garden clubs are officially ‘Not‑for‑Profit’ (NFP) and generally exempt from income tax — registered with an Australian Business Number (ABN) and qualifying under ATO rules for community and sporting organisations qcgc.net+2mayeslaw.com.au+2ATO Community+2mayeslaw.com.au+5Australian Taxation Office+5Australian Taxation Office+5.
Since July 2023, all NFPs with an ABN must complete an annual NFP self‑review form to confirm eligibility Australian Taxation Office+4Australian Taxation Office+4Australian Taxation Office+4.
But this obligation isn’t trivial—it’s triggered fear-driven audits, with some clubs being chased for decades-old trivial income like plant stall surpluses.
Even though they’re registered as NFPs, clubs are being forced to prove their status or lodge full tax returns—then fined heavily if paperwork isn’t perfect qcgc.net+3mayeslaw.com.au+3cprgroup.com.au+3.

The Human Cost

Seniors, retirees, and volunteers are finding themselves targeted with letters, phone calls, and demands beyond their capacity.
Stress has closed clubs and ended community gardens—destroying friendship, purpose, and so much more.
For many, this isn’t a debate—it’s harassment.

Why It’s So Ridiculous

They’re registered NFPs — this isn’t a new business startup. The ATO knows them.
The self-review process is meant to be easy, especially for small clubs cprgroup.com.au+1BDO Australia+1. Yet letters still arrive demanding tax files and old bank statements.
1. Clubs are asked to prove their purpose, even when their constitution clearly states it. It's like forcing you to prove your love for your own home.
1. Any tiny mistake—like selling raffle tickets or refreshments—can trigger a full tax return and penalties.

What Gardening Clubs Need to Know

NFP self‑review now required every year if you have an ABN (unless an ACNC-registered charity) BDO Australia+11Australian Taxation Office+11BDO Australia+11Australian Taxation Office+1Australian Taxation Office+1.
Be clear on your Division 50 tax-exempt category—such as encouragement of a game, sport, or community service BDO Australia+3BDO Australia+3Australian Taxation Office+3.
Keep your governing documents up to date, with clauses reinforcing “assets and income not distributed to members” Australian Taxation OfficeBDO Australia.
Don’t hesitate to declare “Return Not Necessary” if no tax is payable — via the ATO’s phone self-help qcgc.net. Which in many cases has been most unhelpful as reported to this author.

What Needs to Happen Now

The ATO must cease intimidating seniors over pennies and paperwork.
Government should simplify self-review for small volunteer clubs.
MPs and councils need to protect community associations, not penalise them.
Most importantly, gardening clubs must be allowed to flourish, not feared into extinction.

Final Word

These are soil-lovers, not tax dodgers. They grow community—and we mustn’t allow paperwork to replace seed sowing.

Let’s stand with our gardening clubs. Life is too short, and our soil too precious, to let them wilt under paperwork and fear.

Helpful links for clubs:

NFP self-review & annual reporting rules Australian Taxation OfficeAustralian Taxation Office+5cprgroup.com.au+5Australian Taxation Office+5qcgc.netAustralian Taxation Office+12Australian Taxation Office+12BDO Australia+12
Tax-exemption requirements under Division 50 qcgc.net+4Australian Taxation Office+4BDO Australia+4
ATO guidance: "How to report if your social club is not income tax exempt" Australian Taxation Office+10Australian Taxation Office+10Australian Taxation Office+10
Garden‑club‑specific advice from Queensland Garden Clubs cprgroup.com.au+4qcgc.net+4ATO Community+4

It’s time we stand up for our elders, our communities, and our gardens.

Bureaucracy should never choke out joy — or tomatoes.

Back to blog